Yes. You don't need a very low-carb diet to keep weight off. What matters most is the kind of carbohydrates you eat. Build on fruit, vegetables, potatoes, beans, and whole grains, and keep refined carbs and added sugar low. That's also what the 2025 to 2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend.
Quality beats quantity
A plain baked potato and a bag of potato chips are both "carbs," but they behave nothing alike. The potato is filling, full of water and fiber, and hard to overeat. The chips are engineered to be impossible to stop eating. Most of the trouble comes from refined carbs and added sugar, not from carbohydrates as a whole.
What the research says
In a large Stanford study, people on a healthy low-carb diet and people on a healthy low-fat diet lost about the same amount of weight over a year. The common thread was eating real, minimally processed food, not cutting one nutrient to the bone.
What the guidelines say
- Choose whole grains, two to four servings a day, with an emphasis on fiber-rich ones.
- Eat fruit and vegetables every day.
- Minimize refined carbs like white bread, crackers, and packaged breakfast foods.
- Avoid added sugar as much as possible.
Watch what goes on top
Plain potatoes won't make you gain weight. The butter, cream, cheese, and sour cream piled on top are another story. Enjoy your carbs, and keep an eye on the extras.
Get your own protein, carb, and fat numbers with the Maintenance Macro Calculator, and see The Food Map for the best everyday carbs.
New here? Start the free Weigh to Stay program →